What Failure in Afghanistan? - Fareed Zakaria, Washington Post opinion.
At the heart of Gen. Stanley McChrystal's request for a major surge in troops is the assumption that we are failing in Afghanistan. But are we really? The United States has had one central objective: to deny al-Qaeda the means to reconstitute, to train and to plan major terrorist attacks. This mission has been largely successful for the past eight years. Al-Qaeda is dispersed, on the run and unable to direct attacks of the kind it planned and executed routinely in the 1990s. Fourteen of the top 20 leaders of the group have been killed by drone attacks. Its funding sources are drying up, and its political appeal is at an all-time low. All this is not an accident but rather a product of the US presence in the region and efforts to disrupt terrorists, track funds, gain intelligence, aid development, help allies and kill enemies.
It's true that the security situation in Afghanistan has deteriorated considerably. While it is nothing like Iraq in 2006 - civilian deaths are a tenth as numerous - parts of the country are effectively controlled by the Taliban. Other parts are no man's land. But these areas are sparsely populated tracts of countryside. All the major population centers remain in the hands of the Kabul government. Is it worth the effort to gain control of all 35,000 Afghan villages scattered throughout the country? That goal has eluded most Afghan governments for the past 200 years and is a very high bar to set for the US mission there...
More at The Washington Post.
Comments
We have to be careful about assumptions. Fareed Zakaria noted in the Washington Post Opinion that "At the heart of Gen. Stanley McChrystal's request for a major surge in troops is the assumption that we are failing in Afghanistan." Currently, we are not failing, nor really wining, in Afghanistan. Rather, progress has been abated because of Hamid Karzais corrupt government and other complex myriad variables. Gen. McChrystals request for a troop surge "implies" that more troops are needed in order to win and not really an "assumption" that we are losing the battle.