Small Wars Journal

A Test for Privatization in Afghanistan

  1. Articles
Fri, 08/24/2018 - 12:25am

A Test for Privatization in Afghanistan

Gary Anderson

Erik Prince, the former CEO of Blackwater has been pushing the privatization of the Afghan war as an alternative to the present strategy of gradually completing the Afghanization of the war. This is obviously a very controversial proposal, but it is one that at least merits some consideration. There is one remote area of Afghanistan that might well serve as a laboratory for privatization - the provision of construction security for the Ring Road in the remote northwestern region. Completing of the road was the most wicked problem I faced in my time in country, and the situation has not improved since I left in 2012.

Completion of the Ring Road is vital if the Kabul government is ever to be able to claim control over the entire nation. At present, vast stretches are uncompleted and it is impossible to get from the main western city, Herat, to Mazar el Sharif – the nation’s northern most metropolis- by road. The primary reason for the lack of progress is drugs. Without a highway system, it is near-impossible for Afghan law enforcement to assert control. Most drug lords call themselves Taliban to give them some legitimacy, but the Taliban’s Haqqani network is also hard at work running poppy through the area. These groups will resist road completion at all cost.

It is impossible for the Afghan Security Forces to continuously project combat power into the region to protect road building. The secret is to convince district and village leaders along the construction route to contribute local security to the workers. In 2012, my district governor worked hard with a Turkish construction consortium to convince local leaders to provide the requisite security. For his trouble, he was killed in an ambush during one of these field trips.

Providing Ring Road construction security would be a scalable test for some form of privatization. The contractor(s) would have two major logistics challenges. The first would be to operate several airfields on which to stage supplies and helicopters to resupply a series of forward operating bases from which the actual security for construction could accomplished.

The second challenge would be just as daunting. The contractor would have to develop a diplomatic understanding of the negotiating culture of the region sufficiently to convince local district and village leaders to provide security forces for their legs along the construction route. Money is an obvious inducement, but so is the lure of markets. With no roads to market for conventional crops, the local farmers are stuck with poppies. They are easy to grow, and the dealers provide the transportation via four- wheel drive vehicles and cross-country animal transport. However, the drug lords control the price which keeps the farmers well within the poverty zone. If the contractors can provide hope to break this cycle, they could well provide the incentive for local cooperation.

The harsh reality is that privatization might be the only realistic hope for Ring Road completion. As previously mentioned, the Afghan government cannot do it and the US and NATO are unlikely to take aboard any major future Afghan projects. The current Afghan government strategy is to hold the major urban areas while conducting see-saw battle for the Pashtun dominated provinces along the Pakistan border. However, the vast unfinished sections of the Ring Road create ungoverned spaces that provides a second front for the already overstretched Afghan security forces to be concerned with. Ring Road completion would close that second front. Completion of the road would be good strategy as well as good economics.

The Chinese are considering using private security on the major Belt Road project through Pakistan but are already finding drawbacks to their planning. We may learn some lessons through their experience.

 President Trump has shown interest in Mr. Prince’s privatization initiative. Allowing contractors to take aboard the Ring Road project would be a reasonable test case. The Pentagon is skeptical- perhaps rightly so. However, if it works on the Ring Road, it is entirely possible that some hybrid of privatization and the present approach might be an effective way forward. If the privatization of the Ring Road project fails, Mr. Trump will at least know that the idea got a fair trial. If it succeeds, we will have taken a great step forward in the war. In Mr. Trump’s words; “what have we got to lose?”

Gary Anderson was a District Support Team Leader in one of the remote districts along the proposed Ring Road route.

 

About the Author(s)

Gary Anderson

Gary Anderson is a retired Marine Corps Colonel who has been a civilian advisor in Iraq and Afghanistan. He is an adjunct professor at the George Washington University's Elliott School of International Affairs.

Comments

branden7879

Sun, 12/04/2022 - 8:55am

Permalink

The thing is Google is a foolish search engine, Google tells itself intelligent and smart, keeps bringing useless updates like helpful content update, but I have seen sites ranking above me with terrible content. Good work Google! Meanwhile do not forget to check out these monitors under 150 price.

crackboot

Fri, 09/09/2022 - 12:21pm

Permalink

Download Software <a href="https://crackboot.com/amtlib-dll-crack/">Amtlib DLL License Code</a>,<a href="https://activatecity.com/passfab-product-recovery-crack/">PassFab Cracked</a> for Antivirus, Internet Download Manager, Multimedia, Graphics Software and License Keys, Activators for Windows & MS Office.

Document management software is a need for every modern business. 

And so is the proper document format, easy-to-use and convenient for exchange and storage.

As PDFs are recognized as a document format of the future, a need to render PDF in HTML is one of the basic ones. You may have been searching for the proper software and stopped by its low speed or inconvenience. Inkit Render will solve your issues with scalability and any quantities of documents that need to be rendered.

SteveHarrison

Thu, 07/21/2022 - 8:49am

Permalink

When looking for an affordable safety app, pay attention to AllsWell Alert App. Thanks to its extensive configuration capabilities, it alert app is universal. Install it if you are a senior spending a lot of time on your own, or a woman seeking advanced personal safety. Also suitable for kids, lone workers, and anyone who wants more security in their everyday lives, the app will give you peace of mind, and your relatives will know that all is well, and no news is good news.

A reputable US-based company known as Wiki Experts INC. concentrates on enhancing your company's online visibility and reputation. Its team is knowledgeable and skilled, and they have a firm understanding of the market. They are experts in creating a Wikipedia page for company and conduct in-depth research to provide a fantastic piece of content that is customized to your needs.

danielscott

Wed, 02/02/2022 - 2:39pm

Permalink

Web Design Lane is a central online hub to buy superb eCommerce solutions for your eCommerce ventures. Reach to unprecedented heights and outdo your rivals from step one. WDL offers wide-ranging solutions for your bespoke sites. Unquestionably, it is the best custom web portal development company entrepreneurs, and enterprises endorse.

devidstewart

Tue, 09/21/2021 - 7:28am

Permalink

If you are struggling with your work, if you have got a looming deadline, or if you wish longer to revise, then a essay writing service
is simply what you need. there's no ought to go anyplace sort all assignment help on your google search bar and post your question here. 
we've got a team of extraordinarily skillful essay typers who will mildew the essay as per your requirements. we tend to forever tried to supply essay writing services in UK to the coed and cut back the tutorial pressure from their shoulders.

 

https://myassignmenthelperonline.com/assignment-writer.html
https://myassignmenthelperonline.com/assignment-writing-service.html
https://myassignmenthelperonline.com/assignment-help.html
https://myassignmenthelperonline.com/assignment-help-expert.html
https://myassignmenthelperonline.com/assignment-help-melbourne.html

halenabob

Sat, 06/19/2021 - 8:56am

Permalink

Due to the war for many decades, everything is lost. People have no shelter, food, or a good education system. Here many of the students are going through tough days because they didn't find the best helper for cheap nursing dissertation papers and hope for better days.

alisahwilson

Tue, 06/15/2021 - 6:17am

Permalink

If you are facing difficulties finding the best assignment help organization in the UK because everyone claims to be the best? Well now you don't need to be confused, AllAssignmentHelp provides you high-quality academic help because students face so many difficulties to write papers and for all the students not easy to do as they require special skills to write and submit an assignment successfully. So we are here for you, you can ask for do my assignment service from our writer team at any time. they will be able to submit the assignment with the given deadline. buy assignments online at an affordable price.
 

jendavis

Fri, 01/22/2021 - 7:56am

Permalink

It is difficult to compare traditional coffee with cold brew. In fact, I like both, but I still need some time to make cold coffeelikeapro. This time I will try to use the same beans for different drinks.

kusmumichael

Tue, 12/22/2020 - 1:23am

Permalink

hire wordpress developer Leading WordPress web development companies offer to hire WordPress developers for a low fee. With our experience in advanced WordPress CMS programming, our trusted WordPress developers provide the best development and customization solutions to help your company survive in a competitive world while increasing your sales

ashleyblossom

Sat, 10/24/2020 - 4:15am

Permalink

The Privatization in Afghanistan isn't the real solution for the locals. By hearing this news, the officials of Afghanistan reacts angrily, this is because the foreign will control the locals of Afghanistan.

 

Ashley - Best Assignment Help,  foreign news editor.

As an editor from CheapEssayWriter, it is more like a transition of a war from privatization to Afghanization really. So much so that Mr.Trump has just said that the American administration likely to have small numbers of their soldiers in Afghanistan which clearly means that this peace process comprises the proposals and negotiations in a bid to end the ongoing war in Afghanistan.