Small Wars Journal

Blog Posts

SWJ Blog is a multi-author blog publishing news and commentary on the various goings on across the broad community of practice.  We gladly accept guest posts from serious voices in the community.

by Dave Dilegge | Tue, 12/07/2010 - 8:08pm | 0 comments
Informed Dissent: One Blogger's Critique of the Afghan War - New York Times book review by C.J. Chivers. Review of Joshua Foust's Afghanistan Journal: Selections From Registan.net. BLUF: "Mr. Foust, though he has softened his language and tone lately, often does not play nice. Few are spared in these pages - generals, diplomats, think-tankers, authors and journalists all suffer Mr. Foust's sting. This wide target selection fits a binding theme. In his assessment, the problems facing the United States in Afghanistan effort are not just grand in scale and complexity, but also, more worriedly, largely misunderstood by those guiding Afghanistan and the West through the war."

Registan.net, a blog focusing on Central Asian affairs, can be found here.

by Dave Dilegge | Tue, 12/07/2010 - 4:52pm | 2 comments
Via e-mail: The Center for a New American Security (CNAS) released today a new report on U.S. Afghanistan strategy authored by CNAS Senior Advisor and Senior Fellow Lieutenant General David W. Barno, USA (Ret.), former commander of U.S. and Coalition Forces in Afghanistan; and Fellow Andrew Exum, a former Army Ranger and civilian advisor to General Stanley McChrystal. In Responsible Transition: Securing U.S. Interests in Afghanistan Beyond 2011, the authors lay out a strategy for the post-July 2011 phase of the war, define the U.S. troop presence and commitment beyond 2014, and offer operational and strategic guidance for protecting U.S. and allied long-term interests in Afghanistan and Pakistan.

In Responsible Transition, Barno and Exum provide policy recommendations - military and political - for how the United States and its NATO allies can get from summer 2011, when U.S. and coalition troops begin to draw down in Afghanistan, to 2014, when U.S. forces transition to a residual force and transfer full leadership of operations to Afghan security forces. Barno and Exum also consider "spoilers," or disruptive events, that could affect the success of any plan, including: a terror attack on U.S. soil originating in Pakistan; an adversarial Pakistan; a resurgent Taliban; and Afghan National Security Forces failure.

Update: "A Responsible Transition", a response by Joshua Foust at Registan.net.

by Dave Dilegge | Tue, 12/07/2010 - 1:18pm | 2 comments
Ann Marlowe, not known for optimistic reporting and commentary on our efforts in Afghanistan, takes a different tone in her Weekly Standard piece entitled Good News, for a Change. BLUF: "... Zabul seems to be on an upward path. One reason is the growing competence of the Afghan National Army here. The notoriously intractable police are also coming along."
by Robert Haddick | Tue, 12/07/2010 - 12:16pm | 0 comments
Kim Kwan-jin, South Korea's new defense minister (and a former four-star general), now says that South Korea will respond to future North Korean military attacks with airstrikes on North Korean targets.

There is a simple and well-known reason why successive South Korean governments have not explicitly made such a public commitment in the past: much of Seoul lies within range of thousands of North Korean cannons and battlefield missiles. That vulnerability has provided the North with "escalation dominance," a fact which hasn't changed even if resolve in South Korea may now be stiffening.

As long as Seoul's vulnerability persists, many will doubt the sincerity of General Kim's retaliatory threat. The most important of these doubters would be decision-makers inside North Korea, who seems to relish an exciting game of chicken.

The South Korean government could remove doubts about the credibility of its policy if it got serious about civil defense preparation in Seoul and elsewhere.

Click through to read more ...

by Dave Dilegge | Tue, 12/07/2010 - 7:12am | 0 comments
Continue on for today's SWJ news and opinion links.
by Dave Dilegge | Mon, 12/06/2010 - 9:52pm | 0 comments
In addition to the SWJ article "The Military's Cultural Disregard for Personal Information" by LTC Gregory Conti, MAJ Dominic Larkin, LTC David Raymond, and COL Edward Sobiesk see "Service Members Face New Threat: Identity Theft" by Matt Richtel in the New York Times. Both were published today.
by Robert Haddick | Mon, 12/06/2010 - 10:06am | 1 comment
On December 1st, Michael Leiter, the Director of the National Counterterrorism Center (NCTC), delivered remarks and answered questions at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS) (click here to view the entire event). NCTC is the U.S. government's central all-source collection point for terrorist data and intelligence. NCTC is also a principal counter-terrorism (CT) analyst and maintains the TIDE terror suspect database, produces daily CT intelligence products, and publishes a variety of CT watch-lists. The NCTC director is also one of the government's primary CT strategists.

Leiter's speech discussed the evolving terror threat and what U.S. citizens should expect from their government's CT efforts. Leiter's remarks had two themes. First, al Qaeda has transformed from a tightly controlled hierarchical organization into a highly diffuse and "headless" movement. Second, although he and his colleagues are striving mightily, Leiter warned that it will be "impossible" to prevent Islamist terrorist attacks inside the United States, especially small-scale attacks such as those experienced over the past year. Leiter recommended that the country adopt an attitude of "quiet, confident resilience" against this prospect. In his view, extravagant responses to non-existential attacks only reward the terrorists and are self-defeating. Leiter's remarks implied that the U.S. military campaign in Afghanistan is at best peripheral to his mission and at worst making his job more difficult.

Click through to read more ...

by Dave Dilegge | Mon, 12/06/2010 - 8:19am | 0 comments
Continue on for today's SWJ news and opinion links.
by Dave Dilegge | Mon, 12/06/2010 - 8:10am | 16 comments
Continue on for SWJ's WikiLeaks news and opinion links.

Posting Cutoff Date is 9 December 2010

by Dave Dilegge | Sun, 12/05/2010 - 8:29am | 0 comments
Continue on for today's SWJ news and opinion links.
by Dave Dilegge | Sat, 12/04/2010 - 6:00am | 3 comments
Several e-mailed items that caught my attention this week:

The U.S. Army Security Assistance Training Management Organization - Via the U.S. Army's STAND-TO! "The U.S. Army Security Assistance Training Management Organization (USASATMO) is a brigade-equivalent command, headquartered at Fort Bragg, N.C., employing more than 260 Soldiers, Department of Army civilians and contractors who are deployed to more than 20 countries throughout the year to meet the requirements of the foreign nations requesting training assistance." More at the link.

November and December 2010 Issue of the CTC Sentinel - The Combating Terrorism Center at West Point contributes relevant scholarly perspectives through education, research and policy analysis to combat terrorist threats to the United States. Read the latest issue of the CTC Sentinel at the link.

The Foreign Fighter Problem: Recent Trends and Case Studies - Audio and video files of the proceedings of a 27 and 28 September 2010 conference sponsored by the Foreign Policy Research Institute and the Reserve Officers Association. The conference brought together recognized academic and analytical expertise to examine recent trends in the foreign fighter phenomenon and explore the particular cases of Somalia, the Maghreb, Yemen, and Afghanistan/Pakistan. The conference report can be found at the link.

World Almanac of Islamism - The American Foreign Policy Council's World Almanac of Islamism is a comprehensive resource designed to track the rise or decline of radical Islam on a national, regional and global level. This database focuses on the nature of the contemporary Islamist threat around the world, and on the current activities of radical Islamist movements worldwide. Browse the Almanac at the link.

A Community Based Approach to Countering Radicalization: A Partnership for America - Dr. Hedieh Mirahmadi with Mehreen Farooq of the World Organization for Resource Development and Education. WORDE is a nonprofit, educational organization whose mission is to enhance communication and understanding between Muslim and non-Muslim communities and to strengthen Muslim institutions that will mitigate social and political conflict. Read their report at the link.

Marines' Instant Gunship Blasts Taliban, Pentagon Bureaucracy - David Axe, Wired's Danger Room. The first Harvest Hawk-modified C-130 arrived in southern Afghanistan in October, just 18 months after the Marines first announced the program. Much more at the link.

22nd Annual SO/LIC Symposium & Exhibition - NDIA event with theme "Defense, Diplomacy, and Development: Translating Policy into Operational Capability". 8 and 9 February 2011 at the Marriott Wardman Park Hotel in Washington, D.C. Much more at the link to include agenda and registration.

Afghanistan and the Culture of Military Leadership - Dr. Lawrence Sellin at Human Events. Opinion piece that argues that while the U.S. military spends billions of dollars on service academies, war colleges, graduate programs and other forms of education in order to train people to think, it then places them inside a bureaucracy that prevents them from doing so. Go to the link for more.

by Dave Dilegge | Sat, 12/04/2010 - 4:55am | 0 comments
Continue on for today's SWJ news and opinion links.
by Robert Haddick | Fri, 12/03/2010 - 6:17pm | 4 comments
WikiLeaks reveal the U.S. reluctance to employ airpower against Iran. But are cyberattacks and covert assassinations any more effective?

Here is the latest edition of my column at Foreign Policy:

Topics include:

1) Has a war on Iran already begun?

2) U.S.-Russian negotiations over New START are not over.

Has a war on Iran already begun?

This week's WikiLeaks release of State Department cables highlighted the growing concerns of numerous Sunni Arabs leaders over Iran's nuclear program. Bahrain's king, for instance, pleaded to a U.S. diplomat that the Iranian nuclear program "must be stopped." In another leaked cable, King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia supposedly implored the United States to "cut of the head of the snake" (presumably referring to the government in Tehran) before it was too late.

But how to stop the Iranian nuclear program? In yet another leaked cable, U.S. Defense Secretary Robert Gates dismissed the traditional way, an air campaign, concluding that it "would only delay Iranian plans by one to three years, while unifying the Iranian people to be forever embittered against the attacker." Left unsaid by Gates, but no doubt at the front of his mind, are the bitter consequences of the U.S. military campaigns in Iraq and Afghanistan. For its efforts in these two very visible wars, the United States spent a huge fortune, lost thousands of soldiers and earned opprobrium from many quarters of the world. It is little wonder why Gates would be quick to find a reason to avoid yet another military commitment.

But Iran also seems to be under assault from a different kind of warfare. First was the arrival of Stuxnet, a highly sophisticated malware worm specifically designed to attack machinery produced by Siemens Corporation, a German industrial conglomerate.

Click through to read more ...

by Dave Dilegge | Fri, 12/03/2010 - 8:25am | 0 comments
Continue on for today's SWJ news and opinion links.
by SWJ Editors | Thu, 12/02/2010 - 4:07pm | 34 comments
The Jedi Knights, aka the Army's School of Advanced Military Studies at Ft.
by SWJ Editors | Thu, 12/02/2010 - 2:44pm | 10 comments

It's being hailed as "revolutionary" and a "game changer". It's the XM-25 Individual Airburst Weapon System. It's now deployed in Afghanistan (AFP, FOX) What say you?

by Dave Dilegge | Thu, 12/02/2010 - 7:58am | 0 comments
Continue on for today's SWJ news and opinion links.
by Dave Dilegge | Wed, 12/01/2010 - 5:02am | 0 comments
Continue on for today's SWJ news and opinion links.
by David S. Maxwell | Tue, 11/30/2010 - 9:01pm | 1 comment
Although today's press briefing and Q&A with Secretary of Defense Robert Gates and Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Admiral Mike Mullen concentrated on the release of the DOD working group's study on the repeal of "Don't Ask, Don't Tell", the SECDEF's response to a Wikileaks question should be disseminated as widely as possible and hopefully someone in the press will pick it up and write about it (a journalist forwarded an excerpt to an e-mail list I belong to) -- see the bolded portion below -- the emphasis is mine. I would say no better words could have been spoken on this issue.

Every PAO should have this in talking points -- if queried, repeat the SECDDEF's words.

Continue on to read SECDEF's remarks.

by Robert Haddick | Tue, 11/30/2010 - 2:29pm | 5 comments
Prior to September 2001, administrators within the U.S. government had their reasons for stubbornly hoarding their agency's secrets. In the wake of the latest Wikileaks episode involving classified State Department cables, some of those reasons are again apparent. The 9/11 Commission concluded that insufficient cross-agency sharing was partly to blame for the disaster. But we are now reminded that sharing brings its own risks. With a million people thought to have access to U.S. Secret-level correspondence and over 800,000 cleared for Top Secret access, the only surprise is that there are not more leaks. The problem of digital security extends beyond Mr. Assange and PFC Manning. Digital transmissions through the existing internet "cloud" will continue, but will increasingly consist of only the most inconsequential data and reports. The transmission of anything really sensitive will revert (if it hasn't already) to pre-Internet methods -- a hand-delivered document, a telephone call, or a face-to-face conversation in a secure room.

Click through to read more ...

by SWJ Editors | Tue, 11/30/2010 - 10:38am | 18 comments
Counterinsurgency on the Ground in Afghanistan by Jerry Meyerle, Megan Katt, and Jim Gavrilis; CNA's Center for Strategic Studies.

This book provides a glimpse into what relatively small military units—teams, platoons, companies, and highly dispersed battalions—have done to roll back the insurgency in some of the more remote areas of Afghanistan. The focus is on counterinsurgency at the tactical and local levels. The book includes 15 vignettes about different units from the US Marines, Army, and Special Forces, the British Army and Marines, the Dutch Army and Marines, and the Canadian Army. The case studies cover ten provinces in Afghanistan's south and east. They describe the diverse conditions these units faced, how they responded to these conditions, what worked and what did not, and the successes they achieved. The research is based almost entirely on interviews with those involved in these operations.

Download the full report here.

by SWJ Editors | Tue, 11/30/2010 - 8:14am | 0 comments
On the occasion of the publication of the first North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) Training Mission in Afghanistan (NTM-A) Annual Report

The Center for Complex Operations in cooperation with NATO Training Mission - Afghanistan invites you to a discussion of progress and developments in Afghanistan's National Security Forces (ANSF). Join members of the NTM-A staff in discussing the past and future of the ANSF.

Wednesday, December 1, 2010

George C. Marshall Hall, Room 155

National Defense University (NDU)

10:30 a.m. until 12:00 p.m.

Click here to RSVP and download a copy of the NTM-A report.

by Gary Anderson | Tue, 11/30/2010 - 7:59am | 20 comments
Has the founder of Wikileaks' become an enemy combatant, and if so, is he a legitimate military target? Julian Assange made a conscious decision to release wartime classified information on his website to the general public. Some of that information is being used by the Taliban to hunt down Afghan individuals who were named as sources for U.S. and Afghan intelligence organizations. At this writing, we don't know how many of those people have been killed or harmed, but they are definitely at risk. This goes beyond the normal exercise of the human right of free expression, and it also goes far beyond journalistic irresponsibility; but has it crossed the line that would cause Assange and his staff to be considered to be enemy combatants in the War on Terror? I believe that it has.

Continue on for more.

by Dave Dilegge | Tue, 11/30/2010 - 7:30am | 0 comments
Continue on for today's SWJ news and opinion links.
by Youssef Aboul-Enein | Tue, 11/30/2010 - 12:58am | 0 comments

The Importance of Understanding How Arab-Muslims

Ideologically Counter al-Qaida:

The Work of Moroccan Writer Muntasser Hamada

Review Essay by CDR Youssef Aboul-Enein, MSC, USN

Foreword by Mr. Gary Greco, Chief, Office of Intelligence Operations, Joint

Intelligence Task Force for Combating Terrorism (JITF-CT)

Those immersed in the business of countering terrorism and threats

to the United States must read copious amount of materials each day.  However,

it is easy to neglect the treasure trove of information and insights afforded by

Arabic authors who comment and analyze terrorist groups like al-Qaida.  Moroccan

journalist Muntasser Hamada represents a new trend among Arab authors who

deconstruct al-Qaida ideologically, philosophically, and theologically.  Arabic

language works attacking al-Qaida offers America's leaders a better way to

define the threat from Violent Islamist Groups who attack Muslims and

non-Muslims alike.  It offers the language by which to disaggregate al-Qaida

from Islamist Groups and those two from Islam.  Commander Youssef Aboul-Enein

has labored for several years bringing to life Arabic works of interest to

America's counter-terrorism analysts and military personnel.  His work is then

used to train better counter-terrorism analysts and prepare deploying units

utilizing fresh Arabic language materials that dissect al-Qaida and its

franchises.  I look forward to the debate and discussion this expose of Hamada's

work will generate among the readers of Small Wars Journal.

Introduction

Muntassir Hamada is a Moroccan journalist and author of three Arabic

books, who thinks deeply about the impact al-Qaida has had on the Arab Muslim

imagination.  The subject of this review essay is Hamada's 2008 work Nahnu wa

Tanzeem al-Qaida (Al-Qaida and Us), which offers valuable insight into Arab

discourse on al-Qaida and Usama Bin Laden.  The book was published by Al-Awael

Printers in Damascus, Syria who maintains the website:

www.darawael.com. 

America's leaders must take the time to understand and pay attention to Arabic

language books that discredit al-Qaida, its leaders, and its ideology.  Such

books provide a way in which Muslims and non-Muslims can better articulate the

threat and disaggregate the fragmented pseudo-intellectualism of al-Qaida's

Islamic narratives from the diverse and rich beliefs of 1.5 billion Muslims. 

The purpose of this essay is to introduce Hamada's work and to expose American

readers interested in counter-ideology to the level of Arab-Muslim discourse

that attacks al-Qaida philosophically, theologically, and ideologically.